Between the NT1 5th Gen and SM58, the NT1 5th Gen comes out ahead in type and connection, while the SM58 wins on max spl. Overall, the NT1 5th Gen scores 71.1 and the SM58 scores 82 on our Mars Score.
Which should you buy?
The SM58 is the clear pick on raw spec strength, leading by 10.9 points on the Mars Score. The margin is wide enough that the underdog only makes sense if its individual strengths line up with what you specifically need.
Pick the NT1 5th Gen if you care most about type and connection. The biggest gaps in its favor are type, connection.
Pick the SM58 if you care most about max spl. Its strongest claims are max spl.
Both ship with comparable polar pattern, so those specs don't separate the two — focus on the differences below.
Bottom line: the SM58 is the safer default. The other model is the right choice only when its specific advantages line up with your priorities.
Why Rode - NT1 5th Gen wins
- ▲Type: Condenser (vs Dynamic).
- ▲Connection: XLR + USB (vs XLR).
Why Shure - SM58 wins
- ▲Max SPL — 5.63% more. 150 dB vs 142 dB.
Spec comparison
Spec
| Spec | Rode - NT1 5th Gen | Shure - SM58 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Condenserlead | Dynamic |
| Polar pattern | Cardioid | Cardioid |
| Frequency response | 20Hz–20kHz | 50Hz–15kHz |
| Max SPL | 142 dB | 150 dBlead |
Connectivity
| Spec | Rode - NT1 5th Gen | Shure - SM58 |
|---|---|---|
| Connection | XLR + USBlead | XLR |
| Headphone out | truelead | false |
Spec-level deep dives
More from the same brands
vsMars is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.